Local Eats
Our Favorite Key West Cuisine
The excitement of Key West is that unique flavors and authentic dining experiences are always just around the corner. Whether it’s a quick coffee or an elegant dinner, our team has evolving recommendations that come straight from our own hearts (and palates). From just-caught seafood to vibrant, island-inspired plates, each bite brings a little piece of the Keys to your table—reserve your spot and taste what we love most.
Our Favorite spots
Tavern N Town
Your choices range from steakhouse favorites to the incomparable seafood bounty that has brought visitors to Key West for generations. Think fine dining with a taste of tapas, specialty cocktails, and more.
Louie’s Backyard
Oceanfront fine dining with fresh seafood and breezy vibes.
Papa’s Pilar
Bold rum, rich history, and island cocktails inspired by Hemingway.
5 Brothers
Iconic Cuban sandwiches and strong café con leche, made fresh daily.
The Docks
Waterfront seafood and cocktails with working harbor views.
Thirsty Mermaid
Cozy raw bar serving fresh oysters, local seafood, and wine.
Shots & giggles
Chill local bar with cold drinks, TVs, and good vibes nightly.
Kermit’s
Famous Key lime pie, dipped, sliced, and totally iconic.
General Horseplay
Creative cocktails, live tunes, and backyard mischief.
First Flight
Garden bar with seafood, house brews, and aviation history.
El Meson de Pepe
Classic Cuban eats and mojitos by Mallory Square.
Mattheessen’s
Fudge, cookies, and ice cream on Duval since forever.